Sunday, January 29, 2012
Matt Stockamp's Revised Topic
New Hypertext Pitch
Thursday, January 26, 2012
Refined Question for the Analytical Hypertext
What risks are incurred in indoctrinating students in a Private Catholic Boarding Schools?
Understand the fact that this is a religious schools and is outside the jurisdiction of the government. This is a private institution and are not subject to the same laws applicable to its public counterpart. However, there may be some trouble when a certain view is forced upon a student who does not share the same faith as the establishment. Going to a Catholic School does not mean one must abide by the teachings of the sect. Therefore, it is alarming when the views of this establishment is forced to a student. For the most part, one should always be allowed to say ‘no.’ What I mean by this is that a student should have the option of opting out of a certain activity if they feel that it is not in compliance with their moral values. Furthermore, there is a certain amount of rigidity in the core curriculum of such schools. It cannot be avoided when the school requires taking ‘Religious’ classes. Yet I firmly believe that one should not have to if one feels that it is not beneficial for him or her.
Problem Hypertext 2
Matt's hypertext proposal
Hypertext Proposal
TSA & Security Theatre
The question is how effective are these techniques.
In Little Brother, Doctorow illustrates the DHS's ineptitude and ineffectuality. Even trivial techniques like putting rocks in shoes completely nullify gait recognition. RFID tracking can be spoofed and tampered with.
Little Brother is fiction, there are many, very serious flaws in the TSA's methods. Coined by Bruce Schneier (one of the book's afterword authors), the term 'security theatre' describes the TSA's impression of security while not actually providing real security. Many argue that the TSA is designed to provide the perception that they are providing security, while not actually doing a good job.
Last summer I took a domestic flight in Australia. There was absolutely no security whatsoever. It was wonderfully refreshing to simply enter the airport, walk to the gate, and step onto the plane. No metal detectors, no x-rays, no scanners, no nothing. I didn't feel any less secure.
Can there be a balance between security and privacy/non-hassle? What are the problems with the TSA's approach and security techniques?
H.T. Proposal
I would like to study the impact and implications of the Patriot Act and compare it to the situation present in the novel, Little Brother. The Patriot Act essentially granted the US government the ability to spy on potential “terrorists” through underhanded methods such as wiretapping. Furthermore, it reduced restrictions on law enforcement agencies’ ability to search various types of private records. Many Americans considered the bill to be a blatant violation of privacy and accused it of being unconstitutional. I believe that Cory Doctorow would stand in staunch opposition of this bill because it intrudes on basic liberties. In many ways, the bill allows many of the same surveillance strategies, such as wire and Internet tapping, that Marcus fights against in the book.
Our History Books
Wednesday, January 25, 2012
Hypertext Proposal
Trash search
Problem Hypertext
When I began to think of a topic for this particular hypertext, I realized that, in general, I trust authority. I trust that the police and the government are doing everything for the benefit of the people as a whole. So I think that my hypertext will be about how I pretty much trust authority and if that is a good or a bad thing. The ironic thing is that I am no saint. I do normal college things that I would not want my professors to know about and I was raised by two very liberal parents who always tell me to go with my gut and what I think is right. But I trust authority and even if I am stupid and/or ignorant I think it would be an interesting topic to write about.
-Maggie
David Newton: Topic Proposal and Doctorow's Answer
Problem-Mallory Miller
Briar's Hypertext
For my research Hypertext, I would like to explore the issue of “terrorism” with an emphasis on airports and airport security. Although this is unlike the bay bridge or BART attacks, it is relevant to me because I have traveled to numerous airports in the US with a huge pair of scissors and never once have been stopped. The second I got to Amsterdam, they scissors were discarded because of their potential threat to others. In Little Brother, the DHS cracks down, but when Marcus switches up the codes they DHS gets flustered. I feel this is happening with the TSA after the 9/11 attacks and would enjoy researching further.
Analytical Hypertext
On the questions of Education:
Public Education vs. Private Education: More on the issue of Private Education.
If Cory Doctorow were assessing the problem, then the answer is a little clear. Then education should be free of indoctrination. It should not force a certain viewpoint but present the data where the student that should be deciding. Forcing a certain view regardless of whether it is good or bad erases the creativity and ability of the students to think freely. They will derive most of their beliefs from only one perspective and possibly reject the others.
Research Hypertext
When thinking about an idea for my hypertext that would be related to Little Brother I thought about the theme of surveillance with an emphasis on school and extracurricular activities. Many schools like my high school would find out things that students did outside of school and would get punished for that. However, I cannot understand why the school is able to punish a student if he is doing something inappropriate outside school but doesn’t affect his behavior within campus. Do they actually have the jurisdiction of punishing us for something we did outside of school?
I think Cory Doctorow wouldn't agree with any type of indoctrination in schools. I think this because of Mrs. Galvez's positive reaction to Marcus when he quoted the declaration of independence in class to counter against Charles' arguments. And then, getting rid of Mrs. Galvez in his story and replacing her with Mrs. Andersen, Doctorow wanted to prove a point that teachers should not be fired because they encourage debate and free thinking.
Tuesday, January 24, 2012
Comic 3 (Rage)

This comic pokes fun at the fact that all of the technologies which Marcus uses to avoid detection are far from bulletproof. While much of these measures are more than effective at hiding the average citizen from basic government or ISP surveillance, far more effective technologies are necessary to hide a "terrorist" from the eyes of the "government's" anti-cybercrime divisions. My basic premise was that, if I could get around Marcus' protection myself, far more capable security specialists employed by the government would be able to do so without much effort.
remixing little brother
Remixing Little Brother - Golkar
I felt that the revolutionary struggle depicted in the book was overly-romanticized. Throughout the novel, there are some overt and implied comparisons of Marcus to some of the greatest revolutionary minds in history, such as Ceasar Chavez. I added my own tinge to this by expanding upon this notion. I chose to compare Marcus to some of the more controversial radicals whose ideals drove them to fight against an authority that they deemed unfit to rule. While their methods were anything but peaceful, their desire for freedom was still very much there.
Matt Stockamp's New Remix
Little Brother Remix
Setting: The year is 2050 and this remix takes place in a public high school history class.
Student:
Excuse me Mrs. Andersen. I was just reading my textbook, American Heroes from the 17th through the 21st Century, and I stumbled upon a man by the name of Marcus Yallow. Why is this kid’s name in a history book along with guys like Abraham Lincoln and Dr. Martin Luther King? I mean what did a 17 year old high schooler ever do to gain such a national legacy?
Mrs. Andersen:
I’m glad you asked that question because I was planning on lecturing on our rights as citizens for freedom, but I can’t think of a better way of explaining this subject than to spend this class talking to you about Marcus Yallow.
In the early 2000s, America and especially San Francisco lived in fear due to terrorism. The Bay Bridge had just been bombed, leaving over 4,000 people dead and an innumerable amount of citizens missing. The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) was on the prowl at every moment, suspecting and accusing multitudes of innocent people of being terrorists. Marcus Yallow was one of these citizens.
After the bombs went off, Marcus was abducted by the DHS and sent to a secret prison on Treasure Island. While he was there, he was interrogated and horribly mistreated. Upon getting released, his life was changed and he swore an oath to take down the DHS and bring back America as the “Land of the Free”.
What many of you will be surprised to hear is that I taught Marcus that same year. I remember he came into class one day just infuriated that I was protecting the DHS and approving of their snoopy behavior because it was the government’s doing who had forced these beliefs on me. He demanded a change in the government and even quoted the Declaration of Independence:
Governments are instituted among men, deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed, that whenever any form of government becomes destructive of these ends, it is the right of the people to alter or abolish it, and to institute new government, laying its foundation on such principles, and organizing its powers in such form, as to them shall seem most likely to effect their safety and happiness.
Marcus Yallow never took anything at face value and by that I mean to say that he was not stupidified by the government or the education system. Marcus stood up for his rights, and believed that the same government that wrote the Declaration of Independence did not have the authority to alter their governing in a way to harm their citizens. He was not stupidified like many of us who go about life accepting what we are told. We are propagandized every day, and a stupidified person accepts this propaganda without a grain of salt. I fell into this category for years, and it breaks my heart that I stood behind an immoral government and berated Marcus for his actions. Own up to your rights and knowledge, and never accept what you are taught without challenging and testing it. Don’t adapt and be passive about the abuse of your rights. Marcus personifies someone who stood up for what he believed in through opposing authority to the point of death for what he believed was the right thing to do.
To answer your question, Marcus stands side by side with American heroes in your textbook because he fought for freedom when this nation was going in the opposite direction of oppression. He is the George Washington of the 21st century. Both of them were anarchists who fought for what they believed was right, and each of them stabilized the nation and brought freedom to the people.
Marcus’s most famous quote comes from the time he was in danger with the DHS: “You can’t get anything done by doing nothing. They’ve taken it from us. The terrorists who attack us are still free – but were are not. I can’t go underground for a year, ten years, my whole life, waiting for freedom to be handed to me. Freedom is something you have to take for yourself.”
Marcus Yallow stood up against the DHS and regained America’s freedom in a time of distress. His legacy leaves him as one of the greatest patriots of our time.
I urge you to not stand idle when you are propagandized or especially when you feel your freedom being taken from you. Fight for what is yours as Marcus and our forefathers have done. Don’t fall into stupidification as I did, but establish your own opinions and challenge authority to whatever level if it contradicts with your civil rights and liberties.
Does that sufficiently answer your question?
Student:
Thank you Mrs. Andersen. That answer is more than enough.
Monday, January 23, 2012
Little Brother Comic Remix
Link to my site: webpages.scu.edu/ftp/nclaghorn (click "Little Brother Remix")
